Starting a new business can be an exciting and challenging journey, especially for those looking to open their own tabletop game store. However, for new store owners, it can be easy to make mistakes that can negatively impact the success of their business.
In this article, we’ll be covering the top 10 mistakes that new tabletop game store owners make and providing tips on how to avoid them. Whether you’re just starting to research opening a store or are in the early stages of setting up shop, this information can help you avoid costly mistakes and increase your chances of success.
From neglecting market research to failing to measure the success of your marketing efforts, we’ll cover all the common pitfalls that new store owners can fall into. By learning from these mistakes and taking steps to avoid them, you’ll be setting yourself up for success in the not too surprisingly competitive world of tabletop game retail.
So, if you’re ready to avoid these mistakes and increase your chances of success, let’s dive in and explore the top 10 mistakes new tabletop game store owners make and how to avoid them.
Mistake #1: Not Conducting Adequate Market Research
One of the biggest mistakes new tabletop game store owners make is not conducting adequate market research. Market research is the process of gathering, analyzing and interpreting data about the market and customers you want to target. This information can help you understand the size and growth of the market, identify potential customers, and identify your competition. Without proper market research, you may be operating in a crowded or non-existent market or not understanding the needs and wants of your target customers.
Common mistakes new store owners make when conducting market research include not researching the local market, not considering the competition, and not conducting surveys or focus groups. These mistakes can lead to a lack of understanding of the market and not being able to target the right customers.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s essential to conduct market research before opening your store. Start by researching the local market and identifying your target customers. Look into the competition and see what they’re doing well and where they’re falling short. Consider conducting surveys or focus groups to get feedback on what customers are looking for in a tabletop game store. Head to your local Small Business Development Center and use the resources they make available to new business owners. With this information, you’ll be better equipped to make informed decisions about your store and stand out in the market and less likely to open just another game store.
Mistake #2: Failing to Develop a Strong Brand
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is failing to develop a strong brand. A brand is more than just a logo or a name, it’s the overall perception that customers have about your business. A strong brand can help you stand out in a crowded market, attract and retain customers, and command a higher price for your products.
Common mistakes new store owners make when developing their brand include not having a unique value proposition (and no, low prices don’t count), not having a consistent branding message and not having a consistent visual identity. These mistakes can lead to a weak or confusing brand that doesn’t resonate with customers.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on developing a strong brand from the start. Start by identifying your unique value proposition and communicating it consistently across all of your marketing efforts. Develop a consistent branding message and visual identity that will be used across all of your marketing materials, including your website, social media accounts and in-store signage. This will help create a clear, consistent and memorable brand that will resonate with customers.
Additionally, it’s important to remember that developing and maintain the brand is not just an one-time effort, it requires consistent work to keep it fresh and meaningful for your target audience.
Mistake #3: Neglecting the Importance of Community Building
Another common mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is neglecting the importance of community building. Building a community around your store can help you attract and retain customers, generate buzz about your store, and create a sense of loyalty among your customers.
Common mistakes new store owners make when building a community include not creating a sense of belonging, not engaging customers on a regular basis, and not listening to customer feedback. These mistakes can lead to a weak community that doesn’t generate repeat business.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on building a strong community from the start. One way to do this is by creating in-store events and tournaments, encouraging customers to share their experiences on social media, and listening to customer feedback. Additionally, use social media to share news, updates, and promotions with your customers, and use it to engage with them regularly.
Another important aspect is to cultivate customer loyalty, be it by offering special discounts, incentives or loyalty rewards for repeat customers, fostering a sense of belonging among them and making them feel valued. By building a strong community, you’ll be creating a group of loyal customers who will not only keep coming back to your store but also recommend your store to others.
Mistake #4: Overlooking the Importance of SEO
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is overlooking the importance of search engine optimization (SEO). SEO is the process of optimizing your website and online content to rank higher in search engine results, which can lead to more visibility, traffic and sales.
Common mistakes new store owners make with their store’s SEO include not optimizing their website for the right keywords, not having a mobile-friendly website and not regularly updating their website with fresh content. These mistakes can lead to a website that doesn’t rank well in search engine results and doesn’t attract enough organic traffic.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on SEO from the start. Start by researching the right keywords to optimize your website and online content for, and make sure to include them in your website’s meta tags, URLs, and headlines. Make sure that your website is mobile-friendly and responsive, since more and more customers are accessing the internet via mobile devices. And keep in mind that SEO is a continuous effort, you need to ensure that your website is regularly updated with fresh, relevant and high-quality content.
Additionally, you should also make sure to use the right schema tags for marking up your store’s details, this will help search engines understand more about your store, and make your listing more prominent in the result pages.
Mistake #5: Not Utilizing Social Media Effectively
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is not utilizing social media effectively. Social media can be a powerful tool for driving sales and engaging with customers, but it’s important to use it correctly.
Common mistakes new store owners make with social media include not having a consistent voice (seeing Branding up above), not having a strategy and not engaging with customers regularly. These mistakes can lead to social media accounts that don’t generate enough engagement or sales.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to create a social media strategy and stick to it. Start by identifying the social media platforms that your target customers use the most, and create accounts on those platforms. Develop a consistent voice and aesthetic for your social media accounts and make sure to post content that is relevant to your customers and your store.
Additionally, make sure to engage with your customers regularly. Respond to comments and messages promptly, and ask for feedback on your products and services. And remember that social media advertising can be a cost-effective way to reach more people and drive sales.
In summary, social media should be an integral part of your digital marketing strategy, but you should use it in a strategic and consistent manner, engaging with your customers regularly and use it to its fullest potential.
Mistake #6: Failing to Create Engaging Content
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is failing to create engaging content. Content marketing is the process of creating and sharing valuable and relevant content to attract and engage customers, ultimately driving sales.
Common mistakes new store owners make with their content include not having a content strategy, not creating content that is relevant to their customers, and not promoting their content effectively. These mistakes can lead to a lack of engagement, low traffic and minimal sales.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on content marketing right from the inception of your business. Start by developing a content strategy that aligns with your business goals and your target audience. Research the types of content that your customers are looking for, and create content that addresses their pain points and interests. Make sure to promote your content effectively across your website and social media channels, and use calls-to-action to drive conversions.
Additionally, consider creating different types of content such as blog posts, videos, infographics, images and social media posts. This will help you reach a wider audience and keep your content fresh and engaging.
In summary, creating and promoting high-quality content is key to engaging customers and driving sales. Make sure to develop a content strategy and focus on creating content that is relevant and valuable to your target audience.
Mistake #7: Neglecting the Power of Email Marketing
Another common mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is neglecting the power of email marketing. Email marketing is a cost-effective and direct way to communicate with your customers, build loyalty and drive sales.
Common mistakes new store owners make with email marketing include not building a large email list, not segmenting their email list and not personalizing their emails. These mistakes can lead to low open and click-through rates and few sales.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on building a large email list from the start. Use sign-up forms on your website, in-store and at events to collect email addresses from customers. Make sure to segment your email list based on factors such as purchase history and engagement, this will help you send more targeted and relevant messages.
Additionally, make sure to personalize your emails by using the recipient’s name and including content that is tailored to their interests and purchase history. This will help increase open and click-through rates, and ultimately drive sales.
In summary, email marketing is a cost-effective and direct way to communicate with your customers, build loyalty and drive sales. Make sure to focus on building a large email list and segmenting it, as well as personalizing your emails to increase their effectiveness.
Mistake #8: Not Running Effective Paid Advertising Campaigns
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is not running effective paid advertising campaigns. Paid advertising can be a great way to reach a wider audience and drive more sales, but it’s important to do it correctly.
Common mistakes new store owners make with paid advertising include not targeting the right audience, not having clear and specific ad goals, and not testing and optimizing their ads regularly. These mistakes can lead to wasted advertising spend and low conversion rates.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on targeting the right audience and having clear and specific goals for your paid advertising campaigns. Use tools such as Facebook and Google Ads to create demographic and interest-based target audiences. Also, be specific with your ad goals, whether it’s getting more website clicks, increasing in-store traffic or boosting online sales.
It’s also important to regularly test and optimize your ads. Use A/B testing to determine which ad copy, images and call-to-action strategies are the most effective, and make changes as necessary. And be sure to track and measure the results of your campaigns, so you know where you’re getting the best return on your investment.
In summary, paid advertising can be a great way to reach a wider audience and drive more sales, but it’s important to do it correctly. Make sure to focus on targeting the right audience, having clear and specific ad goals, testing and optimizing your ads and tracking and measuring the results.
Mistake #9: Not Creating a Unique In-Store Experience
Another mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is not creating a unique in-store experience. A unique in-store experience can help attract customers and set your store apart from the competition.
Common mistakes new store owners make with their in-store experience include not providing a clear sense of direction or layout, not creating an inviting atmosphere and not providing opportunities for customer engagement. These mistakes can lead to a lack of foot traffic and low sales.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on creating a unique in-store experience from the start. Start by providing a clear sense of direction and layout, which will make it easy for customers to navigate your store. Create an inviting atmosphere by using lighting, color and decor that reflects your brand and makes customers feel welcome.
Additionally, provide opportunities for customer engagement by hosting in-store events, tournaments and demonstrations. This will create a sense of community and give customers a reason to visit your store again and again. One caveat here is that having a bunch of people hanging out at your tables near the front of your shop can have the opposite effect and make your game store less inviting to new customers. Having tables away from the entrance or in a separate space is almost always a better option.
In summary, creating a unique in-store experience can help attract customers and set your store apart from the competition. Focus on providing a clear sense of direction and layout, creating an inviting atmosphere and providing opportunities for customer engagement.
Mistake #10: Failing to Measure the Success of Your Marketing Efforts
One final mistake that new tabletop game store owners make is failing to measure the success of their marketing efforts. Measuring the success of your marketing efforts is crucial to understanding what’s working and what’s not, and making data-driven decisions to improve your marketing strategy.
Common mistakes new store owners make when measuring the success of their marketing efforts include not setting clear and specific goals, not using the right metrics, and not regularly reviewing and analyzing data. These mistakes can lead to ineffective marketing strategies and wasted marketing spend.
To avoid these mistakes, it’s important to focus on setting clear and specific goals for your marketing efforts and choosing the right metrics to measure success. Establish a system for tracking and analyzing data, and regularly review and analyze that data to make informed decisions about your marketing strategy.
Use tools like Google Analytics, social media analytics and other web analysis tools to measure website traffic, conversion rates, and other important metrics. And be sure to track the ROI of your marketing campaigns, so you can see which campaigns are driving the most sales and adjust your strategy accordingly.
In summary, measuring the success of your marketing efforts is crucial to understanding what’s working and what’s not, and making data-driven decisions to improve your marketing strategy. Make sure to set clear and specific goals, choose the right metrics, regularly review and analyze data, and track the ROI of your campaigns.
Ready to take your tabletop game store to the next level? Take your digital marketing skills to the next level by checking out our comprehensive 21-day Complete FLGS Digital Marketing Course specifically designed for tabletop game store owners. Our course covers everything from search engine optimization, branding, email marketing, content creation, paid advertising, and social media marketing. It’s packed with actionable tips and strategies to help you drive more sales and attract more customers. Don’t wait, sign up for our course today and start seeing results!
Alternatively, for a more personalized approach, book a consultation call with the Manaverse Marketing Agency. We’ll take the time to understand your store’s unique needs and create a customized digital marketing plan tailored to your business. From optimizing your website for search engines, to creating engaging content and running effective advertising campaigns, our team will help you take your store to the next level. So what are you waiting for? Book your consultation call today and start seeing results!